Choosing the right size circle hook is crucial for trout fishing, especially targeting those vibrant rainbow trout. It can distinguish between a great catch, an ethical release, or an unfortunate mishap. The size of your trout hook influences your chances of hooking a fish and plays a significant role in ensuring the fish’s well-being.

Let’s get into the details and set you up with the best five trout hooks for your next trout fishing adventure.

Hook Size Guide for Rainbow Trout

Understanding which hook size to use can be a game-changer. Here’s a detailed breakdown of the most commonly used hook sizes for rainbow trout, along with their suitable uses, recommended baits, and benefits:

Our Experience and Recommendations

Over the years, through countless fishing trips and lots of trial and error, we’ve gathered valuable insights into the effectiveness of various circle hook sizes. Here are our detailed recommendations based on different fishing scenarios:

Stocked Trout

For stocked trout, we typically use size 8 or size 10 hooks. These smaller hook sizes offer a great balance – they are large enough to hook the fish securely yet small enough to minimize harm. These hooks perform exceptionally well when fishing for trout with PowerBait or worms. The size 8 hook, in particular, is very versatile. It works well in various conditions and with different baits, making it our go-to choice for stocked trout.

I recall a trip to a local stocked lake where the size 8 hooks made a noticeable difference. We had been using larger hooks and missing a lot of bites. Switching from small hook to size 8 increased our catch rate and reduced the number of deeply hooked fish, making release much easier.

Wild Trout

Wild trout are often more cautious and smaller than their stocked cousins. However, we prefer using size 10 or size 12 hooks for these larger fish. These smaller hooks are less intrusive, reducing the likelihood of spooking the fish. Natural baits like small worms or insects work best with these hooks. They provide a natural presentation that entices wild trout to bite without suspicion.

On a trip to a remote mountain and stocked rainbow trout stream, I switched to size 12 hooks after struggling to get bites with larger ones. The difference was immediate. The smaller hooks blended seamlessly with the river and natural bait, and the stocked rainbow trout also seemed much less wary.

Check our recommended Best Trout Lures

Mixed Environments

In streams, rivers, and lakes that contain many species of stocked and wild trout, size 8 hooks are usually the most effective. This size offers a good compromise, suitable for catching larger stocked fish and smaller wild fish. Using PowerBait, salmon eggs, or small worms with a size 8 hook to catch trout also ensures versatility and effectiveness in diverse environments.

Fishing in mixed environments for larger trout can be tricky, but sticking with size 8 hooks has always been a reliable choice. They handle the best hooks for the larger stocked fish without being too intimidating for the smaller, more cautious wild trout.

Check our recommended Best Circle Hooks

Practical Tips and Best Practices for Using Circle Hooks

Using circle hooks requires a slightly different approach than traditional single hooks. Here are some practical tips to maximize your success with single hooks and ensure the welfare of the fish:

1. Inline vs. Offset Hooks

First, we always recommend using inline circle hooks over offset ones. Why, you ask? Well, inline hooks are designed to reduce gut hooking chances. The hook’s point is aligned with the shank, which means it’s more likely to catch in the corner of the fish’s mouth rather than deeper in its throat or stomach. This alignment ensures a cleaner, more humane catch and release process.

Inline hooks are a fantastic choice for beginners and seasoned anglers. They make it easier for anglers to release the fish unharmed, which is what we all want, right?

2. Crimping Barbs

If you’re into catch-and-release fishing, crimping the barbs on your hooks is a must-do. This simple practice makes it much easier to remove the hook without causing additional injury to the fish. Crimped barbs facilitate quicker and less stressful releases, significantly improving the chances of the fish’s survival.

I always carry a pair of pliers with me to crimp the barbs on my hooks. It only takes a second, but it greatly affects how easily the hook comes out.

3. Hook Sharpness

Always check the sharpness of your hooks regularly. A sharp hook is crucial because it penetrates the fish’s mouth more easily. Dull hooks can lead to missed strikes and superficial injuries, which are frustrating and harmful to the fish.

Before each trip, take a few moments to test the sharpness of your hooks. If they don’t bend or catch easily on your fingernail, it’s time to sharpen or replace them.

Using circle hooks effectively requires a bit of a mindset shift from traditional hooks. Here are some insights and tips based on our extensive use of circle hooks:

4. Patience is Key

One of the biggest adjustments when using circle hooks is learning to be patient. Unlike traditional hooks, you don’t need to strike hard when you feel a bite. Instead, apply steady pressure and let the fish hook itself. This technique reduces the risk of injuring the fish and increases the chances of a successful catch.

I remember the first few times I used circle hooks, I instinctively tried to set the hook like I would with a traditional hook. I quickly learned that patience and letting the fish take the bait resulted in more secure and ethical catches.

5. Hook Size and Bait Matching

Matching the best hook size and casting distance with your bait is crucial for successful fishing. For instance, when using PowerBait, ensure that the casting distance adequately covers the best hook size without obstructing the hook point. This setup increases the likelihood of the fish taking the bait and getting hooked properly.

Always make sure your bait presentation looks natural. This entices the fish and ensures the hook can do its job effectively.

6. Hook Removal

When removing the line from the hook, handle the fish gently and ensure your hands are wet to protect the fish’s slime coat. Use needle-nose pliers to remove the line and the hook from the corner of the fish’s mouth. If the hook is deeply embedded, it’s better to cut the line close to the hook rather than trying to remove it forcefully, which can cause serious injury to the fish.

You might want to read: What Size Line For Trout Fishing? Also, check our recommended Fishing lines.

Wetting your hands before handling the fish is a small but crucial step that many anglers overlook. It helps preserve the fish’s protective slime coat, vital for its health and survival.

You should also read our detailed guide on using circle hooks.

Our Field-Tested Techniques

We have field-tested various techniques and sizes of circle hooks in different environments. Here’s a detailed look at what works best in our experience:

Drift Fishing with Worms

When drifting fishing with worms, we prefer using size 8 or 10 circle or barbless hooks only. The worms are threaded onto the hook, leaving a single barbless hook with the point or single hook still exposed.

This setup allows the fishing line and the bait to drift naturally with the current, enticing trout to bite. The key is to let the fish take the bait and swim away, allowing the single hook to still catch in the corner of the mouth.

Bottom Fishing with PowerBait

We use size 8 hooks for bottom fishing with PowerBait. The PowerBait is molded around the hook, leaving the point exposed for float fishing only. A small split shot is added about 18-24 inches up the line to sink the tip of the fished bait to the lake bottom.

This technique works exceptionally well for stocked trout, as the bait floats slightly off the lake bottom, making it more visible and attractive to the fish.

Bobber Fishing with Live Bait

When we fly fish with live bait like minnows or worms under a bobber, we prefer size 10 circle hooks. The live bait is hooked through the fly, lips, or back, allowing it to move naturally in the water. The bobber helps to keep the bait at the desired depth, and the circle hook ensures that the fish hooks itself when it takes the bait.

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Using circle hooks effectively requires avoiding some common mistakes. Here’s what to watch out for and how to correct these errors:

Setting the Hook Too Aggressively

One of the most common mistakes is setting the hook too aggressively. Unlike traditional hooks, circle hooks are designed to let the fish hook itself. Instead of a hard strike, apply steady pressure to set the hook. This technique reduces the risk of injuring the fish and increases the chances of a successful catch.

Using the Wrong Hook Size

Using a bottom hook size that is too large or trout hook sizes that are too small can result in missed strikes or gut hooking. Ensure you choose the appropriate hook size based on the fish size and the bait you are using. Refer to the table above for guidance on selecting the right trout hook bottom size.

Incorrect Bait Presentation

Improper bait-size hook presentation can result in fewer bites and missed opportunities. Ensure that the bait covers the hook adequately without obstructing the hook point. This setup increases the likelihood of the fish taking the bait and getting hooked properly.

Check More Hook Size Charts:
What Size Hook for Surf Fishing?
What Size Hook For Catfish?